The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie — Full Price Comparison 2026

Side-by-side monthly costs for every dog size, plus trial offers, hidden fees, and price history.

Monthly Cost: The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie

Dog WeightThe Farmer's DogOllieDifference
10 lbs$84/mo$105/mo-$21 (The Farmer's Dog cheaper)
20 lbs$123/mo$153/mo-$30 (The Farmer's Dog cheaper)
30 lbs$168/mo$204/mo-$36 (The Farmer's Dog cheaper)
50 lbs$267/mo$285/mo-$18 (The Farmer's Dog cheaper)
70 lbs$375/mo$360/mo-$15 (Ollie cheaper)
100 lbs$540/mo$495/mo-$45 (Ollie cheaper)

Trial Offers Compared

The Farmer's Dog

Trial: 50% off first box

Shipping: Free on all orders

Price is calculated after completing a full dog profile — no upfront pricing on the website.

Ollie

Trial: 60% off first box

Shipping: Free on all orders

60% intro discount only applies to the first box. Second box renews at full price — a 150% price increase after the trial.

Price Increases: Who Raised Prices More?

The Farmer's Dog raised prices 12% in 2024. Ollie raised prices 9% in 2024. The Farmer's Dog had the bigger increase.